Given the current situation and the emerging expense-to-disposable income ratio that even U.S. middle-class families face, redefining poverty is high on the global quality-of-life improvement checklist.
Poverty has long been a term associated primarily with low income and lack of necessities. Traditionally, it is measured by how much people earn, often focusing on daily or monthly income thresholds.
However, this perspective can be overly simplistic, ignoring a significant portion of the population that may struggle to make ends meet while earning a middle-class income. According to a report from the Pew Research Center, nearly 60 percent of middle-class Americans find it challenging to maintain their standard of living due to financial pressures.
What if we expanded our understanding of poverty to include income and the financial burdens middle-class families face? By analyzing disposable income after essential expenses, we can uncover a new understanding of poverty that reflects the realities of individuals living in owned properties yet still facing significant financial challenges.
This article will explore the nuances of poverty in the first world, focusing on the impact of living costs and the relevance of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs in redefining poverty.
Pixabay)
Understanding poverty
Poverty is a multifaceted issue that varies across global contexts. The World Bank defines extreme poverty as living on less than US$1.90 a day, but this metric fails to capture the struggles of those in developed nations. In cultures where consumerism is prevalent, the perception of poverty can differ vastly, often focusing on the ability to participate in societal norms rather than merely surviving.
Historically, poverty has been measured primarily through income. Still, this approach has been criticized for its inability to encompass broader human experience, such as access to healthcare, education, and a stable living environment. Many sociologists like Amartya Sen are convinced that poverty is not just about income, but capability deprivation. This perspective encourages a more holistic view of poverty, including individuals’ and families’ quality of life and well-being.
Middle-class financial struggles
Despite being classified as middle-class, many U.S. families face financial strain that can lead to a precarious living situation. High housing costs, student loan debt, and rising living expenses can consume a significant portion of income, leaving little for savings or discretionary spending. For instance, “house poor” describes individuals with a substantial portion of their wealth tied up in their homes, resulting in limited cash flow for other needs.
A case study from a family in San Diego illustrates this: with a monthly mortgage of 100,000. According to the Pew Research Center, nearly 60 percent of middle-class Americans struggle to maintain their living standards due to financial pressures. This highlights the disconnect between income and actual financial stability.
The role of living costs
Living costs, including housing, food, and education, play a crucial role in shaping the financial landscape for middle-class families. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development recommends that no more than 30 percent of a household’s income should be spent on housing, yet many families exceed this benchmark.
In cities like San Francisco and New York, housing costs can absorb over 50 percent of income, leaving families struggling with other essential expenses. Food prices have also surged, exacerbated by inflation and supply chain disruptions, making it increasingly difficult for families to afford nutritious meals.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, food prices have increased by over 10 percent in 2023. Education costs, particularly for college-bound children, add another layer of financial strain, often leading families to take on debt that can take years to repay.
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs provides a valuable framework for understanding poverty beyond financial metrics. The pyramid illustrates that basic physiological needs — such as food, water, and shelter — must be met before individuals can pursue higher-level needs, such as belonging, esteem, and self-actualization.
When families struggle to provide for their basic needs due to high living costs, they are effectively trapped in a cycle of poverty, regardless of their income level. This perspective encourages us to consider how meeting basic needs is essential for financial security and overall quality of life.
As Maslow stated: “If the only tool you have is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.” In the context of poverty, we must broaden our toolkit to include various measures of well-being, including societal pressures that influence the ability to meet these needs.
Redefining poverty in the First World
Given U.S. middle-class families’ financial pressures, there is a compelling argument for redefining poverty to include these struggles. Traditional metrics focusing solely on income do not adequately reflect the realities of living in high-cost areas or the burdens of debt. Researchers suggest that a new definition of poverty should consider disposable income — what is left after essential expenses — along with factors such as access to healthcare, education, and social mobility.
The OECD has proposed a multidimensional approach to measuring poverty that incorporates these elements, recognizing that income levels do not solely determine financial stability. Policymakers and researchers must adopt these new definitions and measurements better to address the complexities of this dire issue in modern society.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the traditional definitions of poverty may not fully capture the complexities of financial hardship that U.S. middle-class families in developed nations face. Expanding our understanding to include living costs, access to basic needs, and the financial burdens associated with maintaining a middle-class lifestyle can help us better understand poverty in the first world. As we reexamine our definitions and measurements of poverty, we must advocate for a holistic approach that recognizes the struggles of all individuals, regardless of their income level.
By shifting our focus to include the broader context of living standards and basic needs, we can work towards solutions that address the root causes of poverty and promote a more equitable society for all.
What can we do to ensure everyone can access the resources necessary for a fulfilling life regardless of financial status? This question should guide our efforts in redefining and addressing poverty in today’s world.
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, or Pinterest
